Dissenting Opinion of Plessy v. Ferguson

-

 It is no secret that Plessy v. Ferguson was a huge court case in 1896 but it is still impactful to this day. The case of Plessy v Ferguson went through the supreme court with a vote of 8-1. That was dissenting opinion was written by Justice Harlan. 

Writing a dissenting opinion about the topic of separate but equal during the 1890's it would never have worked. Justice Harlan was writing his opinion not for the time he was living but writing it for the future. He wanted the future courts to be using his dissenting opinion to change the law in the future. So when the 1950's hit and they over turned Plessy the dissenting opinion really showed.

The thoughts of Plessy being used to this day does not make any sense, the idea that segregation could be here is mind blowing and to think that everything that has happened such as Plessy and Brown v Board it really tells us that this in not ancient. 




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Town hall on Slavery

-
Image
  Henry Clay was known as the great compromiser. Henry Clay had a way to drive the public insane. Henry Clay created a compromise known as the Missouri compromise. This compromise allowed Missouri to enter in as a slave state and allow Maine to enter in as a free state. This was supposed keep the balance between slave and free state. Henry Clay started bounty hunting. Henry Clay was trying to faze out slavery. Let it happen over time to keep the South from falling. In 1833 he solved the problems he created, Henry Clay owned 60 slaves but released them before his death. Henry Clay paid for all of his slaves education. He tried to make everything better.              
Read more

Board of Regents of California v. Bakke

-
Image
 May it Please the Court:  Good Morning ladies and gentlemen, your honor  Today I stand before you to say that the actions of Allan P. Bakke are not acceptable. This man is trying to argue that he should get a seat in UC Davis School of Medicine and this is just not right. This man was rejected not because he was not smart of enough or because he was white, he was rejected because of his age. The state of California has a diversity quota, this is set in place to allow minorities access to education. Even if this was about race the school is still in the right because of affirmative action. Affirmative Action allows schools to factor race into their admittance decision. There is no denying that Bakke is smart, but he was rejected by more than one school`, your honor if you rule in favor of Mr. Bakke you would be allowing people who get rejected to try and sue in court to get their way. This would set a precedent that would show if you do not get your way then you can sue in the court o
Read more

Reconstruction Video

-
Image
 After watching the video on reconstruction it really opened my eyes to how not that long ago it was. Just in 2015, a kid walked into a predominantly black church said a prayer and opened fire in the middle of the church causing harm to nine victims. This issue goes back years to a time period we call reconstruction. Reconstruction was a time in which we got rid of the old ways and tried to create new ways. In these ways it caused the old whites to be angry with the new way. It caused tension between the old lights and the new lights.  The African American culture was under attack, the old whites were trying to erase everything that has happened. There were many different attempts and different events that have occurred to harm the African American group.  
Read more